Baked Feta Pasta

Creamy, tangy feta surrounded by blistered tomatoes creates pasta magic in this ridiculously simple dish. After watching this recipe blow up online last year, I finally tried it during a weekend when I needed something easy but satisfying. Standing at my counter tossing warm bow ties with that melty cheese-tomato mixture, I genuinely couldn't believe something this simple could smell so incredible. That first bite delivered everything the hype promised – perfectly balanced flavors that tasted like I'd worked much harder than I actually did.

My sister dropped by unexpectedly right as I was making this the first time. She watched skeptically as I literally just threw tomatoes and feta in a dish, but thirty minutes later was photographing her plate to send to her husband. The next week she texted me that they'd made it twice already. Something about melted cheese and burst tomatoes just hits those comfort food buttons perfectly.

Star Ingredients

• Feta cheese - Get the block stuff packed in brine, not the pre-crumbled kind. The block melts properly while the crumbles stay grainy. I've tried both Greek and Bulgarian feta - both work but the sheep's milk ones have better tang.
• Grape tomatoes - These little guys are consistently sweet year-round and burst at just the right time. I've tried regular tomatoes cut up and it's just not the same – too much liquid gets released. The tiny ones concentrate their flavor when roasted.
• Good olive oil - This isn't where you use the cheap stuff. The oil becomes part of your sauce, so that peppery, fruity quality of real extra virgin olive oil makes a difference you can actually taste. I splurge on the bottle from the Italian market for this dish.
• Fresh basil - Dried just doesn't hit the same notes. The fresh stuff adds this brightness that cuts through the richness. I grow basil in the summer specifically for dishes like this. Winter basil from the store works fine too, just warm it between your hands before chopping to wake up the oils.
• Farfalle pasta - The bow tie shape catches little pockets of sauce. I've tried it with spaghetti which was fine, but shapes with nooks and crannies just hold onto that creamy goodness better. Whatever you do, salt your pasta water – it's your only chance to season the pasta itself.

Pin it

Step-by-Step Instructions

Baking Strategy:

Dump those tomatoes in whole – don't bother cutting them. They'll burst naturally in the oven, releasing their juices at exactly the right time. Make sure the feta sits right in the middle so it melts evenly. I've found that covering the dish for half the baking time keeps everything moist, then uncovering lets those tomatoes get those tasty browned edges.

Timing Tricks:

Start your pasta water right when you put the baking dish in the oven. By the time the water boils, adds pasta, and cooks it, the tomatoes and feta will be perfectly done. This timing means everything finishes hot at the same time – no waiting around for one component while another gets cold.

Cheese Magic:

When you first pull the baking dish out, the feta looks like it's just sitting there all softened. But once you start stirring, it transforms into this creamy sauce that coats everything. Don't overmix though – those little pockets of extra-melty cheese are the best bites.

Pasta Control:

Always cook the pasta just shy of what the package says. It'll finish cooking when you mix it with the hot tomato-feta mixture. And save a mugful of that starchy pasta water before draining – sometimes you need a splash to loosen everything up if it seems too thick.

My neighbor Mark insists he "doesn't like feta cheese" but gobbled this up when I brought some over after he helped me move furniture. His wife laughed watching him go back for seconds while still claiming feta wasn't his thing. There's something about how the sharp edges of the cheese mellow during baking that converts even the skeptics.

Company Worthy

This pasta makes perfect dinner party food – impressive looking but almost embarrassingly easy. Serve it in a shallow pasta bowl with extra fresh basil scattered on top for that restaurant vibe. I like to pair it with a simple arugula salad dressed just with lemon juice and black pepper. The peppery greens cut through the richness beautifully.

Switch It Up

You can play with this basic formula in so many ways. I've added sliced chicken sausage to the baking dish for the last 10 minutes for a protein boost. My friend throws in a handful of kalamata olives for extra Mediterranean flair. During summer I sometimes swap half the tomatoes for sweet corn kernels cut straight off the cob. Fresh thyme works beautifully instead of basil when I want a different flavor profile.

Leftovers Legend

This stuff actually reheats surprisingly well for a pasta dish. Store it in a glass container in the fridge for up to three days. When reheating, add a tiny splash of water before microwaving to bring back the sauciness. The flavors actually deepen overnight, making day-two lunch something to look forward to. I've brought it cold to picnics too – it works as a pasta salad when you add extra olive oil after refrigeration.

Pin it

I've made this baked feta pasta at least twenty times since discovering it. Each time I wonder if it'll live up to memory, and each time it delivers that perfect comfort food satisfaction. What I love most is how it takes these familiar ingredients and transforms them into something that feels special enough for company but easy enough for Tuesday night when work ran late. The simplicity makes it perfect for kitchen beginners, while the flavors satisfy even my foodie friends. When something this good comes from a random internet trend, it deserves a permanent spot in the dinner rotation.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different type of cheese?

While feta gives the dish its signature tangy flavor, you can substitute goat cheese for a milder taste. Brie can work too, though it creates a much creamier texture. Block-style Greek or Danish feta works best in this recipe.

→ What if I don't like tomatoes?

You could try other soft roastable vegetables like bell peppers or zucchini, though the tomatoes provide much of the moisture for the sauce. The tomatoes burst during cooking and become much milder and sweeter than raw tomatoes.

→ Can I add protein to this dish?

Absolutely! Grilled chicken, shrimp, or Italian sausage all pair wonderfully with this pasta. Add the cooked protein when mixing in the pasta for a more substantial meal.

→ What pasta shapes work best?

While the recipe calls for bow tie (farfalle), any medium-sized pasta shape that can hold sauce works well. Penne, rotini, or cavatappi are excellent alternatives that catch the creamy sauce in their ridges and crevices.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

The feta-tomato mixture can be baked ahead and refrigerated for 1-2 days. Reheat gently before mixing with freshly cooked pasta. The completed dish is best enjoyed fresh but can be refrigerated and reheated with a splash of water or olive oil to remoisten.