Blue Moon Ice Cream

Blue moon ice cream brings a magical touch to homemade frozen treats with its distinctive color and mysterious flavor profile. The vibrant blue hue immediately captures attention, while the unique combination of vanilla and almond creates that elusive taste that has made this Midwest favorite so beloved. This version balances creamy richness with subtle flavor notes that dance on your tongue, creating an experience that feels both nostalgic and exciting with each spoonful.

Last summer, I made this for my niece's birthday party, and the children were absolutely mesmerized by the color. What surprised me most was how many adults kept coming back for seconds and thirds, trying to identify the mysterious flavor profile. Several guests insisted it tasted better than any blue moon ice cream they'd tried at ice cream shops or from the grocery store.

Essential Elements

• Heavy cream: Provides the luxurious mouthfeel that makes homemade ice cream superior to commercial versions. Its high fat content prevents ice crystals from forming during freezing.
• Whole milk: Balances the richness of the cream while still maintaining a velvety texture. Using lower-fat milk will result in icier ice cream.
• Granulated sugar: Not only sweetens but affects the freezing temperature and texture. Ensuring it's fully dissolved prevents graininess in the finished product.
• Vanilla extract: Forms the familiar base note that grounds the flavor profile. Use pure extract rather than imitation for the best results.
• Almond extract: Delivers that distinctive flavor that defines blue moon ice cream. The small amount adds complexity without overwhelming the palate.

I've experimented with the ratio of vanilla to almond extract extensively, and this proportion creates that perfect mysterious flavor that's not quite vanilla, not quite almond, but distinctly 'blue moon.' When selecting almond extract, I've found that clear rather than brown varieties work best for maintaining that vibrant blue color.

Pin it

Freezing Method

Perfect mixture

In a large glass bowl, combine heavy cream and whole milk, then gradually whisk in sugar using a balloon whisk. Continue whisking for a full 2-3 minutes until the sugar completely dissolves. You can test this by rubbing a small amount between your fingers – it should feel smooth with no gritty texture. This thorough dissolution prevents crystallization during freezing and ensures a silky-smooth final texture.

Flavor infusion

Add vanilla extract and almond extract to the cream mixture, measuring carefully with proper measuring spoons rather than guessing. Too much almond extract can quickly overpower the delicate balance of flavors. Whisk gently but thoroughly to distribute the extracts evenly throughout the mixture. The aroma should be pleasantly fragrant but not overwhelming.

Color creation

Add blue food coloring drop by drop, stirring after each addition until you achieve the perfect shade. Gel food coloring works best as it provides vibrant color without diluting the mixture. Aim for a medium-bright blue that's eye-catching but not artificially intense. Remember that the color will appear slightly lighter in the finished, frozen product than it does in liquid form.

Churning technique

Pour the mixture into your ice cream maker's chilled bowl, being careful not to exceed the manufacturer's fill line as the volume will increase during churning. Turn on the machine and allow it to churn continuously for the recommended time, typically 20-25 minutes. Watch for the mixture to increase in volume and develop a soft-serve consistency. The mixture should hold soft peaks and cling to the dasher when properly churned.

Cherry addition

If using maraschino cherries, drain them thoroughly and pat dry with paper towels to remove excess liquid that could affect the ice cream's texture. Chop the cherries into small pieces and gently fold them into the churned ice cream using a silicone spatula with a few quick strokes. Work quickly to prevent the ice cream from melting, and avoid overmixing which would turn the entire batch pink instead of creating distinct cherry pieces throughout.

Proper setting

Transfer the freshly churned ice cream to a chilled container with an airtight lid. Fill the container quickly but carefully, using a silicone spatula to press the ice cream down to eliminate air pockets. Smooth the surface, place a piece of parchment paper directly on top of the ice cream, then seal with the lid. This double protection prevents freezer burn and ice crystal formation on the surface.

Serving perfection

Remove the ice cream from the freezer about 5-10 minutes before serving to allow it to soften slightly for the perfect scooping consistency. Use a scoop that's been dipped in warm water between servings to create beautiful, round portions. Serve in chilled bowls or waffle cones for the most authentic experience. The ideal serving temperature allows the flavors to fully bloom on your palate while maintaining structural integrity.

I've been perfecting this blue moon ice cream recipe for years, and the breakthrough came when I realized the importance of balancing the extracts. My first few attempts relied too heavily on almond extract, which created a marzipan-like flavor rather than the elusive blue moon taste. The combination of both extracts in the right proportion was key. I also discovered that churning it slightly longer than other ice creams creates that distinctive dense yet creamy texture that makes blue moon so special.

Serving Suggestions

Present scoops of blue moon ice cream in clear glass dishes to showcase the vibrant color. For a nostalgic treat, serve in sugar cones with rainbow sprinkles on top. Create an elevated dessert by pairing with homemade shortbread cookies or crisp wafers for textural contrast. During summer gatherings, I love setting up a make-your-own-sundae bar featuring this blue moon ice cream alongside classic flavors, with various toppings for guests to customize their creations.

Flavor Variations

Try adding white chocolate chips during the last minute of churning for pops of sweetness and texture. Replace the maraschino cherries with mini marshmallows for a rocky road-inspired version that children particularly love. For a more sophisticated flavor profile, add a teaspoon of culinary lavender to the cream mixture during heating, then strain before churning. My personal favorite variation includes a ribbon of homemade raspberry sauce swirled in just before freezing, creating a beautiful color contrast and bright flavor that complements the mysterious blue moon base.

Storage Tips

Store your blue moon ice cream in a shallow, wide container rather than a deep one to maintain the best texture throughout. Place plastic wrap directly on the surface of the ice cream before putting the lid on to prevent ice crystals from forming. Keep ice cream in the back of the freezer where temperature remains most consistent, away from the door. For extended storage beyond two weeks, transfer to smaller containers to minimize air exposure when serving. I've found that using insulated ice cream containers rather than regular plastic significantly extends the premium texture and prevents freezer burn.

Pin it

I've brought this blue moon ice cream to countless summer gatherings, birthday parties, and family reunions over the years. There's something magical about watching people's faces light up when they see that vibrant blue color, and then seeing their surprise when they taste the unique flavor that can't quite be defined. The mysterious quality of blue moon is part of its charm—everyone experiences it slightly differently, but everyone remembers it. Whether you grew up with this Midwest specialty or are trying it for the first time, this homemade version captures that special blue moon magic in every creamy, dreamy bite!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What exactly does Blue Moon ice cream taste like?

Blue Moon has a unique, sweet flavor that's hard to pinpoint exactly. The combination of vanilla and almond extracts creates that distinctive taste often described as similar to Fruit Loops cereal, amaretto, or a subtle fruity flavor with hints of citrus.

→ Do I need an ice cream maker for this recipe?

While an ice cream maker produces the best texture, you can make a no-churn version by whipping the heavy cream separately until stiff peaks form, then folding in the other ingredients and freezing for 6-8 hours, stirring occasionally.

→ Can I make this without artificial food coloring?

Yes! You can use natural blue food coloring derived from butterfly pea flower tea or blue spirulina powder, though the shade may be more subtle than the traditional bright blue.

→ How long will this ice cream keep in the freezer?

Stored in an airtight container, homemade Blue Moon ice cream will keep for up to 2 weeks in the freezer. For best texture, place plastic wrap directly on the surface of the ice cream to prevent ice crystals from forming.

→ What mix-ins pair well with Blue Moon ice cream?

Besides maraschino cherries, white chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, or rainbow sprinkles make delightful additions that complement the unique flavor and vibrant color of Blue Moon ice cream.