Cheddar Bay Crab Cakes with Lemon Butter Drizzle

I discovered this crab cake recipe last summer when looking for something special to serve at a small dinner party. These aren't your typical Maryland-style crab cakes - the addition of cheddar cheese and that lemon butter drizzle takes them in a completely different direction. The cheese melts slightly during baking, creating these little pockets of gooey goodness throughout, while the outside gets perfectly golden and crisp.

Made these for my seafood-skeptical brother-in-law last month. He's usually the "where's the beef?" guy at family gatherings. After his second crab cake, he asked if I'd write down the recipe for him. My neighbor smelled them baking through the open window and texted asking what I was cooking that smelled so amazing.

Essential Elements

• Lump crab meat: Splurge on the good stuff here if you can. Less expensive claw meat works too, but the texture isn't quite as nice.
• Cheddar cheese: Sharp cheddar gives the best flavor contrast with the sweet crab. Pre-shredded works, but freshly grated melts more smoothly.
• Breadcrumbs: Panko creates the crispiest exterior, but regular breadcrumbs work fine too. The Cheddar Bay biscuit mix substitution is a game-changer if you have it on hand.
• Mayonnaise: This is your binding agent. Real mayo provides better flavor than the light stuff.
• Old Bay seasoning: The classic seafood seasoning that brings everything together. Don't skimp here.
• Fresh herbs: The green onions and parsley add brightness and color that dried herbs just can't match.
• Lemon: Both in the cakes and the butter drizzle, it cuts through the richness perfectly.

Pin it

Crab Cake Creation

Gentle Mixing:

Start by combining all your ingredients in a large bowl. Use a light touch when mixing – you want to preserve those beautiful lumps of crab meat rather than breaking them down.

Perfect Patties:

Shape the mixture into even-sized patties, about 3 inches across and about 3/4 inch thick. If the mixture feels too wet, add a bit more breadcrumbs. Too dry? A touch more mayo does the trick.

Chilling Time:

This step isn't in the original recipe, but I've found refrigerating the shaped patties for about 30 minutes helps them hold together much better during baking. Worth the extra time if you can spare it.

Baking Setup:

Line your baking sheet with parchment paper – this prevents sticking and makes cleanup a breeze. Leave some space between each cake for even browning.

Oven Magic:

Bake at 375°F for about 25-30 minutes. You're looking for that perfect golden-brown color and a slightly crisp exterior. They should feel firm to the touch when done.

Buttery Finish:

While the crab cakes are in their final minutes of baking, prepare the lemon butter. Keep it warm but not hot – you want it melted but not separated. That drizzle over the hot cakes is what makes them truly special.

My first attempt at these was actually a bit of a mess – I didn't chill the patties and tried to flip them halfway through baking, which resulted in crab cake crumbles. Delicious crumbles, but not what I was going for! Now I know to let the oven do all the work. I've also experimented with the cheese – a smoked cheddar adds interesting depth, and a pepper jack gives a nice kick if you like heat.

Creative Switches

While the classic version is hard to beat, there are some fun variations worth trying. Add a diced jalapeño for some heat. Substitute gruyère or fontina for the cheddar for a more sophisticated flavor profile. Mix in some chopped artichoke hearts for an interesting texture contrast. For a smoky twist, add a half teaspoon of smoked paprika to the mixture. And for true indulgence, fold in some lump crabmeat to the lemon butter to make a crab butter drizzle.

Storage Smarts

These crab cakes keep well in the refrigerator for about 2 days. Reheat them in a 350°F oven for about 10 minutes to maintain their crispy exterior. For longer storage, freeze the uncooked patties separated by parchment paper in an airtight container. They can go straight from freezer to oven – just add about 5-7 minutes to the baking time. The lemon butter can be made ahead and refrigerated, then gently reheated.

Pin it

I've made these cheddar bay crab cakes for everything from casual family dinners to fancier celebrations. There's something about the combination of sweet crab, savory cheese, and bright lemon that just works magic together. My dad, who grew up on the Chesapeake and considers himself a crab cake purist, was skeptical about the addition of cheese – until he tried them. Now he requests them whenever he visits. These have become one of my signature dishes, the kind friends and family specifically ask for. Sometimes the most memorable recipes are the ones that break a few rules.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use imitation crab meat for this recipe?

While real lump crab meat provides the best flavor and texture, you can use imitation crab in a pinch. Chop it finely and expect a different texture in the final crab cakes.

→ How do I keep my crab cakes from falling apart?

The key is chilling the formed patties for at least 30 minutes before cooking. This helps the binders (eggs and mayo) set up properly so the cakes hold together during baking.

→ Can I pan-fry these crab cakes instead of baking them?

Absolutely! Heat 2-3 tablespoons of oil in a skillet over medium heat and cook the crab cakes for about 4-5 minutes per side until golden and cooked through.

→ What sides pair well with these crab cakes?

These crab cakes go wonderfully with a fresh green salad, roasted asparagus, corn on the cob, or a light coleslaw. For a heartier meal, serve with roasted potatoes or rice pilaf.

→ Can I make these crab cakes ahead of time?

Yes, you can form the patties up to a day ahead and refrigerate them covered. You can also fully cook them, refrigerate, and reheat in a 325°F oven for 10-15 minutes until warmed through.