Cookie Butter Caramel Cheesecake

This cookie butter caramel cheesecake has become my ultimate crowd-pleaser dessert. I discovered this recipe last year when looking for something special to bring to a holiday gathering that wasn't the usual pumpkin or apple dessert. The combination of spiced cookie butter, creamy cheesecake, and rich caramel sauce creates this perfect balance of flavors that makes people think you spent all day in the kitchen. Everyone always asks for the recipe, and I've even had friends request it for their birthdays instead of traditional cake!

Last Christmas, I brought this to my sister's dinner party. My brother-in-law Mark, who normally just takes a polite bite of dessert, ate an entire slice and then went back for seconds. My sister texted me the next day saying he asked when I might be making it again! Now it's become my signature dessert that everyone expects me to bring to family gatherings.

Key Ingredients

• Biscoff cookies: Create that perfect spiced crust that complements the cookie butter filling. They're those delicious caramelized cookies you sometimes get with coffee. You could substitute graham crackers, but the Biscoff cookies add that signature speculoos flavor.
• Cookie butter: The star of the show! This spread (also known as Biscoff spread or speculoos spread) adds that distinctive spiced caramel flavor that makes this cheesecake unique. I've found it in most grocery stores in the peanut butter aisle.
• Cream cheese: The foundation of any great cheesecake. Make sure it's completely softened to room temperature for the smoothest filling. I leave mine out for at least an hour before starting.
• Brown sugar: Enhances the caramel notes in the cookie butter and adds depth to the sweetness. Light or dark brown both work well, though dark gives a slightly more intense flavor.
• Caramel sauce: The perfect finishing touch that ties everything together. Store-bought works perfectly fine, but if you have time, homemade takes this over the top. I sometimes add a pinch of sea salt to the caramel for a sweet-salty contrast.

Pin it

Step-by-Step Instructions

Perfect crust texture:

The ratio of cookie crumbs to butter creates a crust that holds together when sliced but isn't overly greasy. Pressing it firmly into the pan helps it hold together beautifully.

Room temperature ingredients:

This is non-negotiable for a smooth filling! Cold cream cheese will leave lumps no matter how long you beat it. I set my ingredients out at least an hour before mixing.

Gentle mixing:

Especially important for the baked version. Once you add the eggs, mix just until incorporated. Overbeating adds too much air, which can cause cracks and affect the texture.

Cooling strategy:

For the baked version, letting it cool gradually prevents the top from cracking. I turn off the oven, crack the door open, and let it cool slowly before refrigerating.

Chilling time:

Don't rush this step! The time in the refrigerator allows the flavors to meld and the cheesecake to set up properly. Overnight is truly best for the most developed flavor.

Caramel drizzling:

Add the caramel just before serving for the prettiest presentation. I like to drizzle some on the plate first, then place the slice on top, and finish with more caramel.

I've been tweaking this recipe for a while to get it just right. My first attempts had too much cookie butter, which overpowered the cheesecake flavor. The ratio in this recipe creates the perfect balance where you get that distinctive cookie butter taste but still know you're eating cheesecake. I also experimented with different amounts of caramel before finding that sweet spot where it enhances rather than dominates.

Serving Ideas

Serve this cheesecake well-chilled for the best flavor and texture. For an elegant presentation, pipe whipped cream rosettes around the edge and sprinkle with crushed Biscoff cookies. At holiday gatherings, I sometimes add a few whole Biscoff cookies standing upright around the edge for dramatic effect. This pairs beautifully with coffee, especially something with caramel or vanilla notes.

Tasty Twists

Try adding a teaspoon of cinnamon to the filling for an extra spiced flavor that's perfect in fall and winter. For chocolate lovers, drizzle melted chocolate along with (or instead of) the caramel sauce. During the holidays, I sometimes add a tablespoon of bourbon to the filling for a grown-up version. For a fun variation, make mini cheesecakes in a muffin tin lined with paper liners - they're perfect for parties and take less time to chill.

Storage Smarts

This cheesecake keeps beautifully in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. Cover it loosely with foil rather than plastic wrap to prevent the topping from sticking. For longer storage, you can freeze the cheesecake without the caramel topping for up to a month; thaw overnight in the refrigerator, then add freshly drizzled caramel before serving. I often make the cheesecake portion a day or two ahead, then add the toppings just before serving.

Pin it

I've made this cookie butter caramel cheesecake for countless gatherings, from casual dinner parties to holiday celebrations. There's something about that combination of spiced cookie butter and rich caramel that appeals to almost everyone. It's familiar enough to be comforting but unique enough to feel special. Even better, it's one of those desserts that actually tastes better when made ahead, which makes entertaining so much easier. It's become one of my signature desserts – the one that friends and family specifically request when they know I'm bringing something sweet!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What is cookie butter?

Cookie butter is a spread made from crushed spiced cookies (like Biscoff/Speculoos). It has a consistency similar to peanut butter with a sweet, cinnamon-spiced flavor.

→ Can I make this cheesecake without a springform pan?

Yes! You can make individual servings in dessert cups or ramekins, or use a deep pie dish lined with parchment paper for easy removal.

→ What's the difference between the baked and no-bake versions?

The baked version (with eggs) has a denser, more traditional cheesecake texture. The no-bake version is lighter and more mousse-like in texture.

→ Can I make this cheesecake ahead of time?

Absolutely! This cheesecake actually tastes better after chilling overnight. You can make it 1-2 days ahead and add the toppings just before serving.

→ Can I freeze this cheesecake?

Yes! Freeze the cheesecake without toppings for up to 2 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator and add the caramel sauce and whipped cream before serving.