Easter Poke Cake

I stumbled onto this Easter poke cake recipe last spring when I needed something festive but easy for our family gathering. The combination of that colorful, marbled cake with creamy pudding filling and fluffy whipped cream creates this incredible dessert that looks like you spent hours making it, though it's actually pretty simple. It's become our Easter tradition, bringing just as much joy in the making as in the eating.

My sister-in-law watched me make this last Easter and immediately asked for the recipe, saying it looked way more complicated than it actually was. Sometimes the simplest recipes create the biggest impressions, especially when they're as pretty as this one.

Simple Ingredients

• White cake mix - The perfect blank canvas for creating those beautiful pastel colors
• Greek yogurt - The secret ingredient that makes the cake extra moist and tender
• Gel food coloring - Creates more vibrant colors without thinning the batter
• Instant pudding - Seeps into the poked holes for pockets of creamy goodness
• Fresh whipped cream - That light, airy topping that completes the whole dessert

Pin it

Cake Creation

Batter Preparation

Adding Greek yogurt to the cake mix creates a more tender, moist cake than just following the box directions. I beat the batter for the full two minutes to incorporate air, which helps the cake rise nicely. When dividing the batter, I use a measuring cup to ensure each bowl gets the same amount for balanced colors. The gel food coloring really is key here - it creates those vibrant pastel shades without making the batter runny like liquid food coloring would. I start with just a tiny amount and add more as needed until I get those perfect Easter pastels.

Marbling Technique

The key to a beautiful marble effect is alternating spoonfuls of each color and not overthinking the pattern. I drop random dollops of each color throughout the pan, making sure they touch and overlap. That light swirl with a butter knife creates just enough blending without muddying the colors. The first time I made this, I swirled too much and ended up with a kind of muddy green-purple cake. Now I just do a few gentle figure-eights with the knife and call it done. Each cake turns out with a unique marble pattern, which is part of its charm.

Hole Poking Strategy

Using the handle of a wooden spoon creates the perfect-sized holes for the pudding to seep into. I space them about an inch apart throughout the cake, making sure to get close to the edges too. That gentle wiggle to widen the holes is crucial - it creates more space for the pudding without tearing the cake. I've found that poking holes about two-thirds of the way down preserves some solid cake at the bottom while still allowing plenty of pudding to soak in. The holes might look too big at first, but once filled with pudding, they create those perfect pockets of creaminess.

Pudding Application

Working quickly after mixing the pudding is important since it starts to set up fast. I pour it immediately over the cake, focusing on filling the holes first, then spreading the remainder evenly over the top. Using a rubber spatula to gently press the pudding into the holes ensures they're well-filled. That chilling time allows the pudding to set up and soak into the cake, creating that signature poke cake texture that's somewhere between cake and pudding. Sometimes I add a drop of the same food colorings to the pudding for extra festive flair.

Whipped Cream Perfection

Beating the cream until it forms stiff peaks gives the topping stability while keeping it light and fluffy. I make sure both the cream and the mixing bowl are well-chilled for the best volume. The granulated sugar dissolves during beating, creating a just-sweet-enough topping that contrasts beautifully with the sweeter cake and pudding layers. I often add a splash of vanilla extract to the cream for extra flavor. Spreading it all the way to the edges creates a nice seal that helps keep the cake moist.

Festive Finishing

The coconut grass is both delicious and decorative, adding texture and a classic Easter touch. For extra color, I sometimes tint a portion of the coconut with a drop of green food coloring for a more grass-like appearance. Adding Easter sprinkles and mini chocolate eggs creates that Easter basket look that kids absolutely love. I place them in little groupings rather than sprinkling randomly for a more intentional design that makes the cake look like it came from a bakery.

My normally picky niece actually helped me decorate this cake last Easter, carefully arranging chocolate eggs in patterns on top. She was so proud of the finished product that she made sure everyone knew which part she had decorated. Creating those memory-making moments is sometimes the best part of holiday baking.

Perfect Pairings

Serve this festive cake with coffee or tea for an afternoon treat. For Easter dinner, it makes a beautiful centerpiece dessert alongside fresh fruit for a lighter option. Some guests prefer it with an extra scoop of vanilla ice cream for an indulgent twist. My kids love it as an after-dinner treat with glasses of cold milk.

Creative Variations

Try different flavor combinations like chocolate cake with chocolate pudding for chocolate lovers. Swap the vanilla pudding for lemon or coconut for a different flavor profile. Add a layer of fresh berries between the pudding and whipped cream for a fruity twist. Last spring, I experimented with different extract flavors in the whipped cream - almond was particularly delicious with the vanilla pudding.

Pin it

I've made this Easter poke cake for family gatherings, church potlucks, and school events, and it never fails to bring smiles. There's something magical about those colorful swirls combined with the creamy pudding and fluffy topping that appeals to both kids and adults. My daughter has started helping me make it each Easter, carefully dropping in the colored batters and decorating the top, creating a sweet tradition that I hope she'll continue with her own family someday. Sometimes the most memorable recipes are the ones that bring us together in both the making and the enjoying.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a different cake flavor?

Yes! Yellow or vanilla cake mix works great too. Just remember that darker cake mixes won't show the pastel colors as vibrantly.

→ How far in advance can I make this cake?

You can make it 1-2 days ahead. If making more than 12 hours ahead, consider using Cool Whip instead of homemade whipped cream to maintain stability.

→ Can I use regular food coloring instead of gel?

Yes, though gel food coloring gives more vibrant colors without thinning the batter. If using liquid coloring, you might need more drops for the same intensity.

→ Why is my cake soggy in the middle?

Make sure to let the cake cool completely before adding pudding, and don't make the poked holes too large or too close together.

→ Can I freeze leftovers?

Freezing isn't recommended as the texture of the whipped cream and pudding will change when thawed.

→ What other toppings work well with this cake?

Try pastel M&Ms, chopped Cadbury eggs, jelly beans, or Easter-themed candy for festive variations.