Pin it
Nothing brings back childhood memories quite like the iconic Good Humor Strawberry Shortcake ice cream bars. This clever dessert mashup captures that nostalgic strawberry crunch coating but pairs it with the gooey, crispy comfort of homemade Rice Krispie treats. The combination creates something entirely new yet instantly familiar – like meeting an old friend wearing a fabulous new outfit.
I first made these for my niece's birthday party last summer, thinking the kids would love them. What I didn't expect was the stampede of adults hovering around the dessert table, asking who made "those pink things." My brother in law grabbed three pieces before dinner even started, claiming he needed to "make sure they were good enough for the kids." Now they're requested at every family gathering.
Simple Ingredients
- Mini Marshmallows: The smaller size melts more evenly than regular marshmallows—fresh bags work much better than stale ones hiding in your pantry
- Strawberry Jello: Creates that authentic strawberry shortcake flavor without any actual berries—the powdered mix works magic here
- Vanilla Pudding: The counterpoint to the strawberry that creates the iconic two tone crunch—always use instant pudding mix, not the cook and serve variety
- Marshmallow Fluff: Adds an extra layer of gooey goodness that regular marshmallows can't achieve—don't skip this secret weapon
- Butter: The backbone that brings everything together—unsalted gives you better control over the final flavor
I discovered the perfect ratio of strawberry to vanilla crunch through pure trial and error. My first batch was way too heavy on the strawberry side, practically glowing pink. Several batches later my kids didn't complain about testing, this version hits the nostalgic flavor balance just right.
Pin it
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Strawberry Magic
- Combine strawberry jello powder with butter and flour until it forms a thick paste. The mixture will seem too dry at first, but keep working it—the butter will eventually incorporate completely. The same goes for the vanilla mixture in a separate bowl. Keeping these separate until baking preserves the distinct two tone effect that makes the original ice cream bars so recognizable.
- Careful Baking
- Spread both mixtures on a parchment lined baking sheet, gently pressing to create thin layers. The oven time is critical—too long and they burn, too short and they won't set properly. Watch for bubbling around the edges as your signal they're done. The mixtures will still seem soft when you remove them, but they firm up dramatically during cooling.
- Cooling Patience
- Those two hours of refrigeration aren't optional—attempting to break up warm crunch mixture creates a sticky mess rather than crispy crumbles. The cooling time allows the sugars to crystallize properly, creating that characteristic "snap" when you bite into them. The freezer step before using ensures they stay distinct when mixed into warm marshmallow.
- Marshmallow Mastery
- Melting butter before adding marshmallows prevents burning and creates the smoothest texture. Keep the heat medium low and stir constantly—marshmallows can go from perfectly melted to scorched in seconds. Adding that cup of unmelted mini marshmallows at the end creates delightful pockets of extra gooeyness throughout the treats.
- Gentle Mixing
- When incorporating the Rice Krispies and strawberry crunch, use a folding motion rather than aggressive stirring. This preserves the airiness of the marshmallow mixture and prevents the cereal from crushing. The goal is coating everything evenly while maintaining texture integrity.
- Perfect Pressing
- Transfer the mixture to your prepared pan while still warm and spreadable. The instruction to "press down just enough" is truly critical—too much pressure compacts the treats into dense bricks, while too little leaves them falling apart. Aim for just enough pressure to create a cohesive layer that holds together when cut.
- Finishing Touches
- The marshmallow fluff drizzle and final strawberry crunch sprinkle aren't just for looks—they reinforce the flavor profile and create textural contrast. Heating the fluff in short bursts prevents it from becoming too liquid; you want a thick drizzle that sits on top rather than soaking in completely.
My first attempt at the strawberry crunch turned into a pink sticky disaster because I tried rushing the cooling process. The next batch, I forced myself to wait the full two hours, and the difference was night and day. Sometimes kitchen patience really does pay off, even for someone as impatient as me.
Serving Style
These treats shine when cut into generous squares and arranged on a simple white platter—the vibrant pink pops beautifully against a neutral background. For parties, consider cutting into smaller two bite pieces for easier snacking. A whimsical touch is serving them alongside vanilla ice cream, nodding to their ice cream bar inspiration. They pair surprisingly well with afternoon coffee for grown ups or cold milk for the kids.
Creative Variations
Transform this basic concept using different flavor combinations. Try lime jello with graham cracker crumbs for a key lime pie version, or orange jello with vanilla for a creamsicle twist. During holiday seasons, peppermint extract in the marshmallow base with crushed candy canes on top creates festive Christmas treats. For chocolate lovers, cocoa powder in the base with crushed Oreos in place of the strawberry crunch makes an entirely different but equally delicious variation.
Storage Secrets
Keep these treats in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days. Separating layers with parchment prevents sticking and preserves the crunch topping. These don't freeze well as the cereal loses its crispy texture upon thawing, becoming oddly chewy. For gifting, wrap individual squares in waxed paper and tie with string—they hold their shape well and make delightful homemade presents.
Pin it
I've been tweaking this recipe for three summers now, each batch getting a little closer to perfection. What started as an experiment born from nostalgia has become something my family and friends ask for by name. There's something magical about transforming simple ingredients into something that bridges generations—kids love the colors and sweetness while adults get transported back to chasing ice cream trucks on hot summer days. Some recipes become signatures not because they're complicated, but because they connect us to happy memories while creating new ones.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I use store-bought strawberry crunch topping instead of making my own?
- Yes! You can find pre-made strawberry crunch topping or strawberry shortcake crumbs in many grocery stores or online. Using about 1¼ cups of store-bought topping will save you significant prep time. Just be sure to crush any larger pieces before mixing into the Rice Krispie mixture.
- → How long do these treats stay fresh?
- These treats are best enjoyed within 2-3 days. Store them in an airtight container at room temperature, with parchment paper between layers to prevent sticking. Don't refrigerate them as this can make them too hard and lose their gooey texture.
- → Can I make these with other flavors of Jello?
- Absolutely! Try raspberry, cherry, or even lime Jello for different flavor variations. Just pair with vanilla pudding mix as directed for that classic ice cream bar flavor contrast. You could even do a combination of flavors for a unique twist.
- → Why did my Rice Krispie treats turn out hard instead of gooey?
- Hard Rice Krispie treats usually result from pressing the mixture too firmly into the pan or cooking the marshmallows too long. Be sure to remove the marshmallow mixture from heat as soon as it's melted, and when adding to the pan, press just enough to make them hold together but not so much that they compact.
- → Can I make these treats ahead of time for a party?
- Yes, you can make both the strawberry crunch topping and the treats a day ahead. For the freshest taste and texture, assemble everything the day before your event, and add the marshmallow fluff topping and final sprinkle of crumbs just a few hours before serving.