Jello Creamsicle Pie

I discovered this no-bake wonder during a miserable August heatwave when even standing near the oven seemed unbearable. The combination of orange and vanilla flavors wrapped up in a fluffy, creamy filling brings back those childhood memories of chasing down the ice cream truck. This pie manages to capture that perfect creamsicle taste while being incredibly easy to throw together. The buttery shortbread crust adds a rich base that balances the light, citrusy filling beautifully.

Cool Perfection

• No need to turn on the oven, keeping your kitchen comfortable even in summer heat
• Can be made ahead, giving you one less thing to worry about when entertaining
• Works as both a soft mousse-like dessert or frozen treat depending on how you serve it
• The familiar orange-vanilla flavor appeals to both kids and adults alike

My neighbor Tom, who claims he's "not a dessert person," ate two slices of this at our block party last July and then casually asked if I might have any leftovers he could take home. His wife rolled her eyes and told me he talks about "that orange pie" every time the weather gets hot now.

Must-Have Ingredients

• Shortbread cookies make the most buttery, delicious crust. I've tried using graham crackers when I was out of shortbread once, and it was good but not quite as rich.
• Real oranges provide that fresh, authentic flavor that makes all the difference. The zest especially adds this incredible aroma you just can't get from artificial flavoring.
• Orange Jello might seem old-fashioned but it's essential for that nostalgic creamsicle taste and helps the filling set properly. Don't substitute here.
• Cream cheese gives the filling structure and that subtle tanginess that balances the sweetness. Remember to let it soften properly or you'll be fighting lumps forever.
• Cool Whip creates the perfect light, fluffy texture. I attempted making this with homemade whipped cream once, but it didn't hold up nearly as well.

My first time making this, I skipped the fresh orange and just used bottled juice. Big mistake! The fresh fruit makes it taste alive rather than like orange-flavored something-or-other. That extra five minutes of effort pays off enormously in the final flavor.

Pin it

Step-by-Step Instructions

Dish Prep

Spray your pie dish with cooking spray even though it seems unnecessary with all that butter in the crust. Trust me on this - my first attempt turned into a serving disaster when half the crust stuck to the dish. Better safe than sorry!

Crust Making

Pulse those cookies into fine crumbs and mix with melted butter until it resembles wet sand. Press firmly into your pie dish and up the sides. I use the bottom of a measuring cup to pack it down evenly - works way better than just using my fingers and creates a more uniform crust.

Crust Chilling

Pop the crust in the freezer while you make the filling. This quick-chill helps it set up so it doesn't fall apart when you add the wet filling. I've found 15 minutes is enough, but you can leave it longer if you're multitasking or get interrupted (story of my life).

Orange Blast

Blend the orange segments, zest, vanilla, and juice until smooth. This fresh mixture is what gives the pie its authentic flavor. The first time I made this, my food processor was broken so I tried mashing by hand - not recommended unless you enjoy orange pulp everywhere and an uneven result!

Base Building

Beat the cream cheese and Jello powder together until smooth. Make sure your cream cheese is properly softened - I've ruined more than one filling with cold cream cheese lumps. The mixture will look alarmingly bright orange at this stage but don't worry, it mellows when you add the other ingredients.

Fluff Factor

Fold in the sweetened condensed milk and Cool Whip gently. Emphasis on gently! I once rushed this step and deflated all the air, resulting in a dense rather than fluffy filling. Use a rubber spatula and a light hand to maintain that airy texture we're after.

Orange Addition

Beat in your orange puree until everything is well combined. The filling should be a beautiful pale orange color and smell absolutely amazing. It will be softer now but still thick enough to hold its shape when scooped.

Fill and Chill

Pour the filling into your chilled crust and smooth the top. Now decide - refrigerator for soft-serve texture or freezer for a more ice-cream-like result? I usually split the difference with an hour in the freezer followed by a transfer to the fridge, which gives the perfect texture.

Topping Time

Whip the remaining cream cheese and Cool Whip for the topping. This step is technically optional, but it adds another layer of creaminess and makes the pie look so much more impressive with minimal effort.

Final Touch

Just before serving, add the topping and orange slices. I usually dollop the cream around the edges and arrange the orange slices in the center. If I'm feeling fancy, I'll add a sprinkle of zest over the top for color and that amazing citrus aroma.

Helpful Hints

• This pie actually improves overnight as the flavors meld together
• For the best flavor balance, use navel oranges which are sweeter and less acidic
• The texture varies dramatically depending on whether you chill or freeze it

My daughter requested this for her birthday instead of cake last year. I was worried the other kids might find it too "grown-up," but they devoured it and asked what flavor of ice cream it was! Now I keep the ingredients on hand all summer long for last-minute get-togethers.

Serving Style

Serve this beautiful pie on a simple white plate to make the orange color pop. For summer gatherings, I sometimes garnish the plate with additional orange slices and mint leaves for a fancy restaurant look. It pairs wonderfully with iced tea or, for adult gatherings, a dessert wine. The pie holds up well at room temperature for about an hour, making it perfect for backyard parties.

Flavor Twists

Try adding a teaspoon of Triple Sec to the filling for an adult version with a bit more complexity. During winter holidays, I sometimes use a gingersnap crust instead of shortbread which adds a spicy warmth that works surprisingly well with the orange. For chocolate lovers, drizzle the top with a bit of melted dark chocolate just before serving - the orange-chocolate combination is absolutely divine!

Fresh Keeping

Store covered in the refrigerator for up to a week (though it rarely lasts that long in my house!). For longer storage, keep it in the freezer for up to three months. If frozen solid, let it sit at room temperature for about 15 minutes before slicing for the perfect consistency. When taking to potlucks in summer heat, I transport it in a cooler with ice packs to maintain that perfect creamy texture.

Pin it

Pie Wisdom

• Run your knife under hot water before cutting for the cleanest slices
• If the filling hasn't set enough, pop it in the freezer for 30 minutes before serving
• For a quick version, use a pre-made shortbread crust from the store (I won't tell!)

I've made this Jello Creamsicle Pie so many times I could probably do it blindfolded now. There's something magical about that combination of orange and vanilla that just screams summer to me. My husband now judges the official start of summer not by the calendar, but by when this pie first appears in our refrigerator. Sometimes the simplest recipes become the most requested family favorites!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use a pre-made crust instead of making my own?

Yes! A store-bought graham cracker crust will work well as a time-saving alternative. You could also use a pre-made shortbread crust if available. Just be aware the pie might not be as deep, depending on the size of the pre-made crust.

→ How long does this pie need to chill before serving?

For a soft-serve consistency, chill in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours. For a more frozen texture similar to ice cream, freeze for at least 1 hour. The longer it chills, the firmer it will become.

→ Can I use fresh orange juice instead of bottled?

Absolutely! Fresh orange juice will provide the best flavor. You'll need about 1-2 medium oranges to get the required amount of juice, plus another for zesting and slicing for garnish.

→ My pie didn't set properly. What went wrong?

The most common reason is not allowing enough chill time. Make sure to give it at least 2 hours in the refrigerator or 1 hour in the freezer. Also, ensure you used the correct amounts of cream cheese and Cool Whip, as these provide structure to the filling.

→ Can I make this pie with a different flavor of Jello?

Yes! This recipe would work well with many Jello flavors. Try strawberry for a strawberries and cream version, or lime for a key lime-inspired dessert. Just adjust the fresh fruit and juice accordingly to match your chosen flavor.

→ How far in advance can I make this pie?

This pie is perfect for making ahead. You can prepare it up to 3 days in advance and keep it refrigerated, or up to 3 months if kept in the freezer (wrapped well in plastic wrap). Add the topping and garnish just before serving for the best presentation.