Key Lime Pie Rice Treats

I stumbled upon this key lime pie rice krispie treats recipe last summer when I needed something different for a neighborhood potluck. The combination of tangy lime with sweet marshmallows creates these incredible treats that taste like key lime pie but with that nostalgic rice krispie texture. They've become my go-to when I want something unique that doesn't require turning on the oven.

My neighbor stopped by just as these were setting up on the counter, and the aroma of lime and butter convinced her to stay for coffee. After one bite, she immediately asked for the recipe, saying they were the most interesting rice krispie treats she'd ever tasted. Sometimes the simplest recipes create the biggest impressions.

Simple Ingredients

• Key limes - Their distinctive tangy flavor is what makes these treats special
• Graham crackers - Creates that classic key lime pie crust element
• White chocolate - Adds a creamy sweetness that balances the tart lime
• Extra marshmallows - Those additional 2 cups add pockets of gooey goodness
• Lime zest - Provides intense citrus flavor and beautiful flecks of green

Pin it

Treat Creation

Graham Cracker Integration

Chopping the graham crackers into small pieces rather than crushing them completely creates little pockets of crunch throughout the treats. I use a knife rather than a food processor to maintain some texture - you want recognizable bits of graham cracker, not just crumbs. Dividing them between the mixture and the top gives you that nice crust-like element both inside and as a garnish. The first time I made these, I crushed them too fine and lost that distinctive texture that makes you think of key lime pie crust.

Marshmallow Management

Melting the marshmallows over low heat is crucial - too high and they can scorch, giving an off flavor. I stir constantly with a silicone spatula, which doesn't stick to the marshmallows like a wooden spoon might. Adding those extra 2 cups of marshmallows at the end without fully melting them creates little pockets of extra gooeyness throughout the treats. Sometimes I even add a few more than the recipe calls for because we love that extra marshmallow texture.

Lime Incorporation

Fresh key limes make all the difference here, though regular limes work in a pinch. I zest the limes before juicing them - it's much easier that way. When adding the juice and zest to the melted marshmallow mixture, I work quickly to incorporate it before the marshmallows start to set up. The heat from the melted marshmallows helps release the oils in the zest, intensifying the lime flavor throughout the treats. I sometimes add a tiny drop of green food coloring if I want them to look more obviously lime-flavored.

Spreading Technique

Spraying the spatula with cooking spray is a game-changer for working with sticky marshmallow mixtures. I respray it if things start sticking again during the spreading process. Rather than pressing too firmly, which can create dense, hard treats, I use a gentle pressure to spread the mixture evenly in the pan. For the neatest edges, I spray my fingers with cooking spray and use them to smooth the corners and sides. Working quickly is important as the mixture becomes more difficult to spread as it cools.

White Chocolate Drizzle

The white chocolate adds both visual appeal and a creamy sweetness that complements the tart lime perfectly. I melt it slowly to prevent seizing, and the addition of a little oil helps it drizzle more smoothly. Adding lime zest to the white chocolate creates little green flecks throughout the drizzle, making it obvious these aren't just regular rice krispie treats. I use a fork or small whisk to drizzle it in a back-and-forth pattern for the most attractive presentation.

Setting Time

While it's tempting to cut into these right away, that full hour of setting time allows the flavors to meld and the texture to develop properly. I've found that letting them sit at room temperature rather than refrigerating gives the best texture - refrigeration can make them too firm. If I'm in a hurry, I'll sometimes put them in the refrigerator for about 15 minutes, but no longer or they lose that perfect chewy consistency that makes rice krispie treats so irresistible.

My teenage son, who normally passes on anything citrus-flavored, took one bite of these and declared them "actually really good" - high praise from a kid who typically only wants chocolate desserts. There's something about that combination of familiar rice krispie treat texture with the surprising lime flavor that appeals even to citrus skeptics.

Perfect Pairings

Serve these tangy treats with a cup of hot tea for a delightful afternoon snack. For summer gatherings, I pair them with fresh berries for a beautiful color contrast on the dessert table. During brunch, they make a wonderful sweet option alongside savory dishes. My kids love them as an after-school treat with a glass of milk, while I enjoy them with my morning coffee for a slightly indulgent breakfast.

Creative Variations

Try adding shredded coconut to the cereal mixture for a tropical twist. Replace the white chocolate drizzle with a cream cheese glaze for more tanginess. Experiment with different citrus like lemon or orange for new flavor profiles. Last summer, I tried adding finely chopped dried pineapple to the mix, which created a lovely tropical variation that was perfect for a luau-themed party.

Pin it

I've made these key lime pie rice krispie treats for everything from summer picnics to book club meetings, and they never fail to create conversation. There's something delightful about the surprise of that tangy lime flavor in what looks like a traditional treat. My daughter has started requesting them for her birthday instead of cake, which I consider the highest form of culinary praise possible. Sometimes the most memorable recipes are the ones that take a familiar favorite and add an unexpected twist, creating something that feels both comforting and exciting at the same time.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use regular limes instead of key limes?

Yes! Regular limes work well too. Use 2-3 regular limes to replace the 6 key limes in this recipe.

→ How long do these treats stay fresh?

When stored in an airtight container at room temperature, they stay fresh for 4-5 days.

→ Why add some marshmallows at the end?

Adding some marshmallows after removing from heat creates pockets of gooey marshmallow in the finished treats for better texture.

→ Can I make these ahead of time?

Absolutely! These treats are perfect for making a day ahead for parties or gatherings.

→ How do I cut them without making a mess?

Let them set completely (at least an hour), then use a knife sprayed with cooking spray for clean cuts.

→ Can I freeze these treats?

Yes, wrap them individually in plastic wrap and freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw at room temperature.