Loaded Seafood Baked Potato

These loaded seafood baked potatoes happened by accident when I was trying to figure out what to do with some leftover crawfish and shrimp from a weekend boil. My husband suggested just putting it on baked potatoes, and I thought why not make it fancy with a proper cream sauce? What started as a way to use up leftovers turned into one of our most requested dinner ideas because it feels like something you'd get at an upscale restaurant but you're making it at home in your pajamas. My neighbor came over while I was making these last month and the smell from the kitchen had her practically drooling. She ended up staying for dinner and spent the whole meal asking detailed questions about every step. Now she texts me whenever she finds crawfish at the store asking if it's "seafood potato time" again.

What You'll Need

• Large russet potatoes: Get the biggest ones you can find since these are the main event
• Good shrimp: I use medium-large size and keep some tails on for presentation
• Crawfish tails: Frozen ones work fine if you can't get fresh
• Old Bay seasoning: This is what gives the shrimp that classic seafood flavor
• Heavy cream: Don't try to substitute with milk, you need the richness
• White wine: Use something you'd actually drink, nothing fancy but nothing terrible either
• Mixed cheeses: Colby jack and three-pepper cheese make everything creamy and melty
• Fresh garlic and shallots: These build the flavor base for your cream sauce

Pin it

How to Make Them

Get those potatoes started:

Scrub them really well, rub with olive oil and salt, then prick with a fork. Wrap in foil and bake at 400 for about an hour until they're crispy outside and fluffy inside.

Season the shrimp:

While potatoes bake, toss your shrimp with olive oil and all those seasonings. Let them sit and absorb all that flavor.

Cook the shrimp perfectly:

Sear them in a hot skillet with butter and oil for about 3 minutes per side. Don't move them around too much or they won't get that nice golden color. Chop half of them up and leave the rest whole.

Build the cream sauce:

In the same pan, cook your shallots until fragrant, add garlic, then deglaze with wine. Pour in that heavy cream and let it reduce slightly.

Add the seafood:

Season your sauce with all those spices, then add the crawfish and let everything simmer together for a few minutes. Finish with cheese until it's all melted and smooth.

Prepare the potato filling:

Scoop out the cooked potato flesh and mash it with sour cream, milk, and butter. Fold in the chopped shrimp and both cheeses.

Put it all together:

Stuff the potato mixture back into the skins, top with more cheese if you want, then ladle that amazing seafood cream sauce over everything. Sprinkle with green onions for color.

I definitely overcooked the shrimp the first time I made these because I was worried about food safety. They turned out rubbery and disappointing. Now I know that shrimp cook incredibly fast, and the residual heat from the sauce finishes them perfectly. It's all about timing and not being afraid to pull them off the heat when they're just done.

Perfect Serving Ideas

These are pretty substantial on their own, but a simple green salad with lemon vinaigrette goes perfectly alongside. Some crusty bread for soaking up any extra cream sauce never hurts either. I sometimes roast some asparagus or green beans while the potatoes are in the oven for a complete meal.

Ways to Change It Up

Try different seafood combinations, scallops work great in place of crawfish, or use all shrimp if that's easier to find. You could add some crab meat for extra luxury, or even use lobster if you're feeling really fancy. Different cheese combinations work too, gruyere and parmesan create a more sophisticated flavor profile.

Storage Tips

These are definitely best served immediately while everything is hot and the cheese is melty. If you have leftovers, store the components separately and reheat gently. The cream sauce can be reheated on the stove with a splash of cream to bring back the consistency.

Pin it

This recipe has become my go-to when I want to make something that feels like a special occasion without spending all day in the kitchen. There's something really satisfying about how all these simple ingredients come together into something that looks and tastes like restaurant food. Every time I serve these, people get excited and start taking pictures before they even taste them, which always makes me feel like I've accomplished something special in the kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use frozen crawfish tails?

Yes, thaw them completely and pat dry before adding to the sauce. Fresh crawfish will have better texture, but frozen works fine.

→ What can I substitute for crawfish?

Crab meat, lobster, or even more shrimp work well. Adjust cooking time since some seafood cooks faster than crawfish.

→ How do I know when the potatoes are done?

They should feel soft when gently squeezed and the skin should be crispy. A fork should pierce through easily with no resistance.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

You can bake the potatoes and make the sauce ahead. Assemble and reheat in the oven at 350°F until warmed through.

→ What vegetables pair well with this dish?

Simple steamed asparagus, roasted Brussels sprouts, or a crisp garden salad complement the rich seafood flavors perfectly.