Muffin Tin Banana Cream Pies

Muffin tin banana cream pies are a culinary magic trick, delivering the sophisticated look of a boutique bakery dessert with the ease of a simple no-bake assembly. By reimagining the classic pie in individual portions, this recipe replaces the stress of pastry dough with a clever Golden Oreo crust and replaces messy slicing with perfect, bite-sized rounds. Layered with fresh banana slices, silky instant pudding, and airy whipped cream, these mini treats are the ultimate crowd-pleaser for potlucks and family gatherings. It is a high-impact, low-effort masterpiece that proves you don't need an oven to be the star of the dessert table.

I first debuted these at a baby shower when I was asked to provide dessert for thirty people on short notice. Guests were convinced I had spent a fortune at a local patisserie. When I admitted they were made in muffin tins that very morning, three people immediately asked for the recipe. It has since become my signature contribution; everyone just assumes I'm bringing "those banana pie things," and I’m more than happy to oblige given they only take ten minutes of hands-on work.

What You'll Need

• Banana Cream Pudding Mix: Use the instant variety for a quick set. It provides that authentic, nostalgic flavor foundation
• Whole Milk: Creates the richest, most luxurious mouthfeel. For an even firmer set that stands up to party heat, reduce the milk to 1.75 cups
• Golden Oreos: These serve as the "crust." Their vanilla cream filling adds sweetness and acts as a moisture barrier to keep the cookie crunchy
• Fresh Banana: One firm but ripe banana. Centering a quarter-inch slice on the cookie ensures every bite feels like a real fruit dessert
• Whipped Cream: Real whipped cream provides the light, airy finish that balances the dense pudding. Add this just before serving for peak volume
• Mini Nilla Wafers: The perfect scale for a mini dessert garnish, adding a final textural crunch and an adorable "finished" look
• Sturdy Cupcake Liners: Foil or heavy-duty paper liners prevent the pudding from soaking through and make removal from the tin effortless

Pin it

Creating Your Mini Pies

Foundation Construction:

Line your muffin tin with sturdy liners and drop one whole Golden Oreo into the bottom of each cup. Press it down so it sits perfectly level. Place a uniform quarter-inch banana slice directly on top of each cookie. This creates a fruit-filled center that surprises your guests when they take their first bite.

The Pudding Layer:

Whisk the pudding mix and milk vigorously for two minutes. Timing is everything here: you must distribute the pudding into the cups immediately. If you wait, the pudding will set in the bowl and become lumpy. Scoop the mixture into the liners, filling them to the top to create a slightly domed, professional appearance.

The Final Chill and Garnish:

Refrigerate for at least two hours to allow the pudding to firm up and the flavors to marry. Just before the guests arrive, add a generous swirl of whipped cream and a jaunty mini Nilla wafer. This ensures the garnish stays crisp and the cream remains fluffy for the best presentation.

I learned the hard way that rushing the chill time is a recipe for disaster. I once tried to serve these after only an hour, and they were essentially just pudding cups that slid out of the liners. Now, I give them a full two hours (or overnight) to ensure they are firm enough to be eaten by hand. I also discovered that a piping bag for the whipped cream makes these look ten times more expensive with almost zero extra effort.

Creative Variations

Swap the banana pudding for chocolate and use regular Oreos for a "Mud Pie" version. For a tropical twist, use coconut cream pudding and top with toasted coconut flakes. You can even make a strawberry version by adding a slice of berry on top of the banana and using vanilla pudding. For those watching their sugar, sugar-free pudding mix works perfectly with almost no change to the final texture.

Storage and Freshness

These pies stay fresh in the refrigerator for up to 3 days when covered tightly. While the Oreo crust will gradually soften over time, many people actually prefer the cake-like texture it develops by day two. Do not freeze these; the banana and pudding will release water upon thawing, ruining the creamy consistency. For the best experience, assemble the bases and pudding a day ahead, then garnish fresh at the party.

Pin it

Ultimately, muffin tin banana cream pies are a testament to the power of simple, smart assembly. They take familiar, comforting flavors and package them in a way that feels intentional and special. Whether you’re a novice in the kitchen or a seasoned host, these little pies are a guaranteed win that will have your guests reaching for seconds before the first platter is even cleared.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Why do I need thick cupcake liners?

Thin liners can let the pudding seep through or become too flimsy to hold. Thick, sturdy liners keep everything contained and make them easier to handle.

→ Can I use regular Oreos instead of Golden?

You can, but Golden Oreos have that vanilla flavor that goes better with banana cream. Regular chocolate Oreos would taste fine but look a bit different.

→ How long do these last in the fridge?

They're best within 2 days. The bananas can start to brown and the cookies can get soggy if they sit too long.

→ Can I use homemade pudding?

Sure! Just make sure it's thick enough to hold its shape. Cook-and-serve pudding works better than instant for a firmer texture.

→ Why shouldn't I add the whipped cream ahead of time?

Whipped cream can get watery and weep if it sits on the pudding too long. Add it right before serving for the best texture and appearance.

→ Can I freeze these?

Not recommended. The pudding texture changes when frozen and the cookies get soggy. These are best made fresh and kept refrigerated.