Oreo Cake Balls

I stumbled across this Oreo cake balls recipe last summer when I needed something quick for my niece's birthday. These little treats have this amazing contrast - creamy Oreo insides with a snap-crisp candy coating. No oven required, which is a lifesaver during those hot months when turning on the oven feels like torture.

Made these for my sister's baby shower last month. I was running behind on everything and threw these together the night before. Everyone kept asking where I "bought those amazing truffle things." Didn't have the heart to tell them it was just Oreos and cream cheese! My brother-in-law ate seven of them - I counted.

Master Your Ingredients

• Oreo cookies: Don't bother with generic brands here. The original Oreos have that perfect cookie-to-filling ratio that creates the right texture when crushed. Trust me, I've tried the store brands and something's always off.
• Cream cheese: Full-fat works best - I tried reduced fat once and the mixture was too wet. The cream cheese needs to be properly softened or you'll end up with little white lumps throughout your mixture.
• White candy melts: Ghirardelli is worth the extra couple dollars. The cheaper brands can be grainy or too thick for dipping. I've wasted more money trying to salvage cheap chocolate than I would have spent just buying the good stuff.
• Heavy cream: Consider this your emergency backup. Sometimes even good quality melts need a little help, especially if your kitchen is cold. Just a splash makes all the difference.
• Toppings: Fresh Oreo crumbs need to go on while the coating is still wet. I've sworn loudly more than once trying to get toppings to stick to already-set chocolate.

Pin it

Creating Your Perfect Cake Balls

Cookie Crushing:

Dump those 24 Oreos into your food processor and let it run until you've got something that looks like dark, crumbly soil. Don't worry about separating the filling - that's part of what makes these work. Add your softened cream cheese and pulse again until it starts looking like thick cookie dough.

Ball Formation:

I use my cookie scoop to keep them all the same size - learned that lesson after having some too big ones that wouldn't set properly. Roll them between your palms until smooth. Your hands will get messy, and that's just part of the process.

The Crucial Chill:

Line a baking sheet with parchment and arrange your balls with some breathing room. Stick them in the freezer for those 15 minutes - set a timer because you don't want them frozen solid. This step isn't optional; I tried skipping it once and ended up with a melty disaster.

Chocolate Prep:

Microwave those candy melts in a deep, narrow bowl (makes dipping easier). Do 20-second zaps, stirring between. If they're not Ghirardelli, you might need that spoonful of warm cream to thin things out. The consistency should be like smooth cake batter.

Dipping Dance:

Working quickly, drop a cold ball into the melted candy, roll it with a fork to coat, then lift it out. Let the excess drip off, then use a toothpick to help slide it onto the parchment. I usually do five or six, then put the rest back in the freezer while I work to keep them firm.

Finishing Touches:

If you're doing Oreo crumbs on top, you've got about 30 seconds before the shell starts to set. For chocolate drizzle, I put melted chocolate in a sandwich bag, snip the tiniest corner off, and make quick zigzags over the set balls.

My first batch of these was a complete disaster. I didn't chill them enough, and they started falling apart in the hot melted chocolate. Then I overcorrected and froze them solid, which made the coating crack as they warmed up. Now I've got the timing down to a science. And yes, I've eaten the broken ones standing over my sink rather than let them go to waste. No regrets.

Creative Variations

The standard recipe is foolproof, but experimenting is half the fun. Golden Oreos with a few drops of lemon extract in the mix make a bright summer version. Around Christmas, I use the mint Oreos with a drop of peppermint oil added. My husband loves when I mix in tiny peanut butter chips with regular Oreos and coat them in milk chocolate instead of white. Just don't mess with the cream cheese ratio or you'll end up with balls that won't hold their shape.

Storage Solutions

These little guys will stay good on the counter for about three days in a container - any plastic storage thing with a lid works fine. If your house is really warm, maybe stick them in the fridge, but remember to take them out about 20 minutes before serving or they'll be too hard. I've frozen extras before a big event and then thawed them overnight in the fridge - they were still perfect the next day. Just don't freeze them after they're decorated or the condensation will make the pretty toppings all soggy.

Pin it

I make these Oreo cake balls at least once a month now. They're my go-to when someone mentions a potluck or when neighbors drop by unexpectedly. The ingredients live permanently on my grocery list. My kids have started requesting them instead of birthday cake, and my mother-in-law actually asked for the recipe, which is basically the highest compliment possible from her. There's something just magical about that moment when teeth break through the candy shell into the soft, creamy center - comfort food disguised as something fancy.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use different flavors of Oreos?

Yes! You can use any Oreo variety like Golden Oreos, mint, or seasonal flavors. The process remains the same, but each variety will give you a different and delicious flavor profile.

→ How should I store Oreo cake balls?

Store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. You can also freeze them for up to 3 months. Let frozen cake balls thaw in the refrigerator before serving.

→ Can I use milk or dark chocolate instead of white chocolate?

Absolutely! You can substitute any type of chocolate coating you prefer - milk chocolate, dark chocolate, or colored candy melts all work well with the Oreo filling.

→ Why are my candy melts too thick for dipping?

If your candy melts are too thick, add 1-2 tablespoons of hot heavy cream or coconut oil and stir well. Alternatively, specialized dipping aid chips designed for candy melts work best for thinning without affecting the setting properties.

→ What's the best way to dip cake balls smoothly?

For the smoothest coating, make sure the cake balls are very cold (but not frozen solid). Use a fork to dip, tap off excess coating, and slide the cake ball off the fork using a toothpick. Work with just a few cake balls at a time, keeping the rest in the refrigerator.