Peppermint Brownies

December weekends at my house usually mean something chocolatey in the oven, but these peppermint brownies have ruined me for all other holiday treats. Stumbled across this recipe three years ago when looking for something festive to bring to a neighborhood cookie swap. The contrast between that fudgy chocolate base and cool minty frosting with bits of candy cane creates this perfect holiday bite that makes standard brownies seem boring by comparison. Anyone who tries them immediately asks for the recipe - happens every single time.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

• The combo of fudgy brownies with cool mint frosting is basically Christmas in your mouth
• They look fancy but require zero decorating skills to pull off
• The candy cane pieces soften slightly into the frosting, creating perfect texture
• They taste even better the next day when flavors have melded together

Made these for my daughter's dance recital party last December and watched a room full of normally restrained dance moms lose their minds. One literally followed me to my car asking for details. The secret isn't anything complicated - just nailing that perfect balance between rich chocolate and cool mint without letting either overpower the other. Took me a few batches to get it right, but now it's foolproof.

Ingredients

• Unsalted butter gives you control over the salt level. I tried using salted butter once when that's all I had in the fridge. They turned out fine but the salt competed with the delicate mint balance.
• Quality cocoa makes or breaks these brownies. Dutch-processed gives smoother flavor, but regular cocoa works perfectly fine too. Just don't use hot chocolate mix - learned that mistake the embarrassing way.
• Fresh eggs create that perfect crackly top when properly incorporated with the sugar. Cold eggs straight from the fridge lead to dense, flat brownies without that signature shine.
• Pure vanilla extract might seem unnecessary with all the peppermint, but it creates depth in the chocolate layer that would be noticeably missing otherwise.
• All-purpose flour needs precise measuring for the fudgiest texture. Too much creates cake-like brownies instead of that dense, rich texture that makes these irresistible.

Pin it

Step-by-Step Instructions

• Proper Preheating matters more than you'd think. My ancient oven runs cool, so I set it to 365°F instead of 350°F. Getting to know your oven's quirks makes all the difference.
• Gentle Butter Melting prevents the burnt butter taste that ruins everything. I melt it slowly on medium-low heat, removing it the second it liquifies completely.
• Sugar Incorporation requires thorough whisking with melted butter until slightly lighter in color. Rushing this step creates grainy texture you'll definitely notice later.
• Egg Addition happens one at a time, mixing thoroughly between each. This creates that perfect emulsion that gives brownies their distinctive texture and shiny top.
• Careful Folding introduces dry ingredients without developing gluten. I use a silicone spatula and stop the second the flour disappears - overmixing creates tough brownies.
• Timing Tricks depend on your preference for fudgy versus cakey brownies. For the fudgiest version, remove when a toothpick comes out with a few moist crumbs still clinging to it.

You Must Know

• Different brands of peppermint extract vary wildly in strength
• These taste even better after sitting overnight
• The center pieces are fudgier than edge pieces
• Cutting with a plastic knife prevents dragging the candy cane pieces

My first attempt at these brownies was nearly ruined by using way too much peppermint extract. The frosting tasted like toothpaste. Learned quickly that different brands vary tremendously in potency, and measuring carefully matters. Now I add extract drop by drop, testing as I go. My mom suggested adding the crushed candy canes, which wasn't in the original recipe. That simple addition created both visual appeal and textural contrast that transformed them completely.

Perfect Pairings

Serving these on vintage Christmas plates creates instant holiday vibes without any effort. They look stunning displayed on a cake stand surrounded by pine branches or cinnamon sticks for natural decoration. Hot chocolate with homemade whipped cream alongside creates the perfect winter dessert experience. For grown-up gatherings, try serving with peppermint schnapps hot chocolate for a boozy twist that perfectly complements the flavors.

Clever Variations

Drizzle melted dark chocolate over the frosting before adding candy canes for extra richness and visual impact. White chocolate chips folded into the brownie batter create wonderful sweet pockets that balance the mint beautifully. For serious chocolate lovers, try using half semisweet chocolate chips melted with the butter for deeper chocolate intensity throughout the brownie base.

Fresh Storage

These brownies keep beautifully at room temperature for 4 days in a sealed container. The mint flavor actually deepens slightly over time, making them perfect for making ahead. If stacking, place parchment between layers to prevent sticking. Refrigeration makes them denser and fudgier, which some people prefer, though I like them best at room temperature. Freezing works surprisingly well - just thaw unwrapped at room temperature and add fresh candy cane pieces if the original ones lost their color.

Pin it

Baker's Secrets

• Line your pan with foil instead of parchment for easier removal and cleaner cuts
• Chill brownies for 30 minutes before cutting for professional-looking edges
• Slightly underbake for that perfect fudgy middle that makes people swoon

These peppermint brownies have become my signature holiday contribution. Friends and family start asking about them before Thanksgiving even hits. There's something magical about the combination of deep chocolate with bright mint that embodies the season perfectly. What started as a random recipe has become firmly embedded in our family traditions. My son, who normally avoids mint anything, makes an exception just for these brownies. Even my mother-in-law, who criticizes literally everything I bake, asks for the recipe every single year and then pretends she's forgotten it by the next Christmas.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make these brownies ahead of time?

Yes! These brownies stay fresh for up to 3 days in an airtight container at room temperature or up to a week in the fridge.

→ Can I freeze peppermint brownies?

Absolutely. Freeze them in an airtight container with parchment between layers for up to 3 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator.

→ What if I don't have peppermint extract?

You can crush extra candy canes and mix them into the frosting, though the flavor won't be as strong as using the extract.

→ Can I use box brownie mix instead?

Sure! Prepare the box mix according to package directions, then add the peppermint frosting and candy cane topping once cooled.

→ How do I know when the brownies are done baking?

A toothpick inserted in the center should come out with a few moist crumbs, not wet batter. Don't overbake or they'll lose their fudgy texture.