Strawberry Pie

I've been chasing the perfect strawberry pie recipe since my grandma took me to Shoney's as a kid. That gorgeous red pie with plump berries suspended in jewel like glaze left an impression that's lasted decades. After years of tweaking, this version nails that nostalgic taste that makes everyone at the table fall silent with the first bite.

My aunt begged me for this recipe after I brought it to her Memorial Day cookout last year. Her exact words were, "I haven't had this since I was a teenager! How'd you get Shoney's to give you their recipe?" The simple ingredients and method make this possibly the easiest impressive dessert in my summer rotation.

Simple Ingredients

• Fresh Strawberries: The absolute stars of the show—look for bright red berries without white shoulders for the sweetest flavor
• Store Bought Crust: Don't waste time making crust when nobody will notice the difference in this pie—the berries and glaze are what matter
• Strawberry Gelatin: Creates that signature glossy red suspension that makes this pie instantly recognizable—nothing else works quite the same
• Cornstarch: The secret thickening agent that gives the glaze body without cloudiness—don't substitute flour here
• Sugar: Balances any tartness in the berries and helps the glaze set properly—regular granulated works perfectly

I tried making this with fancy pie crust and honestly couldn't tell the difference once it was filled with berries and glaze. My grandmother who was known for her pies admitted to me years ago that she always used frozen crusts for fruit pies. If it's good enough for Granny, it's good enough for me!

Pin it

Simple Steps

Crust Preparation

Bake that store bought crust according to package directions until it's golden brown around the edges. The pre baking step is crucial—a raw crust would get soggy under all those juicy berries. Let it cool completely before filling or you'll end up with melted glaze and soft berries.

Berry Selection

Choose the prettiest, most uniform berries for this pie since they'll be on full display. Hull them carefully, removing the green tops without cutting away too much fruit. Leaving them whole creates that classic Shoney's look, though you can halve any giants so they don't tower above the others.

Glaze Creation

The cornstarch, sugar, and water mixture needs to reach a full boil to activate the thickening properties properly. You'll see it change from cloudy to clear as it boils—that's your signal it's ready. Adding the gelatin off heat preserves its setting power while incorporating it completely into the glaze.

Cooling Period

That room temperature cooling for the glaze isn't just a suggestion—it's critical. Hot glaze poured over fresh berries would partially cook them, turning your beautiful pie into sad, mushy strawberries floating in red liquid. Patience here makes all the difference in the final presentation.

Careful Assembly

Pour the cooled glaze slowly over the arranged berries, using a spoon to direct it into all the nooks and crannies. You want every berry to have a light coating that will set into that perfect shiny finish. Any excess will fill in around the berries, creating that signature suspension effect.

Chilling Time

The overnight chill or at least 4 hours isn't negotiable—the gelatin needs time to set completely. Cutting into it too soon creates a messy slice that won't hold its shape. The waiting is torture but results in those picture perfect slices that stand up on the plate.

The first time I made this, I got impatient and poured warm glaze over my berries. They released their juice, partly dissolved the glaze, and created what my husband kindly called "strawberry soup in a crust." Lesson learned: sometimes shortcuts just create more work in the end.

Serving Style

This showstopper deserves proper presentation. Serve slices on white plates to showcase the vibrant red color. A generous dollop of whipped cream on top isn't just traditional—it's the perfect creamy counterpoint to the sweet berries. For nostalgia inducing authenticity, use Cool Whip, though freshly whipped cream with a touch of vanilla elevates it for company. A sprig of fresh mint adds a beautiful color contrast if you're feeling fancy.

Seasonal Switches

While this pie shines brightest with perfect summer strawberries, you can adapt it year round. In early spring, mix strawberries with rhubarb pre cooked and cooled for a tangy variation. Late summer allows for a mixed berry version—blackberries and blueberries create beautiful color contrast while maintaining that classic gel suspension. For winter months when fresh berries are expensive and flavorless, a version using good quality jarred or frozen cherries thawed and drained with cherry gelatin creates a holiday worthy alternative.

Storage Smarts

This pie keeps beautifully in the refrigerator for 3 4 days, though the crust will soften slightly over time. Cover with plastic wrap rather than aluminum foil, which can react with the gelatin and affect flavor. Never freeze this pie—the gelatin structure breaks down when thawed, creating a watery mess. For transporting to gatherings, chill until completely set, then carry in a pie carrier with an ice pack underneath.

Pin it

I've been making this pie every summer since finding this recipe fifteen years ago. It started as a way to recreate childhood memories but has become a tradition my own kids now associate with summer gatherings. There's something magical about serving a dessert that bridges generations—people who remember the restaurant original get nostalgic while younger folks just appreciate a delicious, beautiful pie. Sometimes the simplest recipes become the ones that create the strongest memories.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use frozen strawberries instead of fresh?

Fresh strawberries are strongly recommended for this recipe. Frozen strawberries will release too much moisture as they thaw, resulting in a soggy pie with a compromised texture. The firmness and appearance of fresh berries are what give this pie its authentic look and texture similar to the restaurant version.

→ How far in advance can I make this strawberry pie?

This pie can be made 1-2 days in advance and stored in the refrigerator. The gelatin needs at least 4 hours to fully set, but overnight chilling gives the best results. Keep in mind that the pie is at its best within the first 3-4 days, as the crust may begin to soften from the moisture of the berries and glaze if stored longer.

→ What can I use instead of strawberry gelatin?

If you prefer to avoid packaged gelatin, you can make a homemade version using unflavored gelatin, additional sugar, and strawberry puree or strawberry juice. Mix 2 tablespoons unflavored gelatin with 1/4 cup cold water, then add to the hot sugar/cornstarch mixture along with 1/2 cup strawberry puree and a few drops of red food coloring if desired.

→ Why didn't my glaze set properly?

The glaze may not set properly if the cornstarch mixture wasn't brought to a complete boil (which activates its thickening properties), if measurements were off, or if the pie wasn't chilled long enough. Make sure to boil the cornstarch mixture until it's noticeably thickened and allow at least 4 hours of chilling time, preferably overnight, for the gelatin to fully set.

→ Can I make this pie with other fruits?

Yes! This recipe works well with other berries or fruit combinations. Try raspberries, blackberries, or a mixed berry version. You can match the gelatin flavor to your fruit choice (raspberry gelatin with raspberries, etc.) or stick with strawberry gelatin as a base for any fruit. Firmer fruits like peaches or blueberries work particularly well.