Banana Pudding

So this banana pudding recipe has been my family's go-to dessert for pretty much forever. My grandma used to make it for Sunday dinners, and I snagged the recipe from her little handwritten recipe box after she passed. It's one of those desserts that doesn't look like anything special, but then people take a bite and their eyes get all wide. The combo of soft vanilla wafers, sweet bananas, and that creamy pudding mixture is basically comfort in a bowl. Plus, it's ridiculously easy to throw together.

Why You'll Love This Recipe

• You don't have to turn on the oven - perfect for summer!
• It actually tastes better after sitting overnight in the fridge
• People always think you worked way harder than you did
• Kids and adults go equally nuts for it

Last Memorial Day, I brought this to my neighbor's cookout. Their dad was visiting from Georgia and apparently hadn't had "proper" banana pudding in years. He took one bite and got this faraway look in his eyes. Then he asked if he could have the recipe to take back home. His daughter told me later he'd been talking about "that amazing banana pudding" all week. Southern food nostalgia is no joke, y'all.

Key Ingredients

• Instant vanilla pudding mix - Could I make pudding from scratch? Sure. Do I want to stand over a hot stove stirring forever? Absolutely not. The instant stuff works perfectly here.
• Sweetened condensed milk - This is the secret ingredient that makes people think you made some complicated custard from scratch. It adds this rich caramel-y undertone that takes everything up ten notches.
• Vanilla wafers - Don't even think about using generic here. I've tried. Trust me, name-brand Nilla Wafers have the perfect texture and vanilla flavor. The cheap ones turn to mush.
• Fresh bananas - Obviously important! You want them ripe with some brown spots, but not banana bread territory. Too green and they taste weird, too brown and they get slimy.
• Whipped topping - I know food snobs will say to use real whipped cream, but the stabilized stuff from the freezer section holds up way better for this. I've tried both, and the real whipped cream starts to weep and collapse by day two.

Pin it

Pudding Magic

• The two-minute whisking - Set a timer on your phone for this part. Two minutes of whisking feels like forever, but if you cut it short, the pudding won't set up right. My arm always gets tired about halfway through, but keep going!
• Folding technique - When you add that whipped topping, use a gentle touch. I usually cut down the middle with my spatula, then scoop from the bottom up and over. Rotate the bowl and repeat. The first time I made this, I stirred it like soup and knocked all the air out.
• Layer strategy - Always start with a thin layer of pudding on the bottom of your dish! Rookie mistake is putting wafers down first - they'll float up if there's nothing to anchor them. Ask me how I know...
• Waiting game - The hardest part of this recipe is waiting for it to chill. Four hours is the absolute minimum, but overnight is when the magic really happens. The wafers get this cake-like texture that's impossible to describe but completely addictive.
• Banana prep - Only slice the bananas right before you're ready to assemble. One time I sliced them ahead while getting other ingredients ready, and they turned brown before I could even use them. Lesson learned.

You Must Know

• Don't make this more than 2 days before serving - the bananas will get weird
• The wafers are SUPPOSED to get soft - that's not them going stale!
• This tastes way better cold than at room temperature

I've tweaked this recipe so many times over the years trying to get it just right. My first few attempts didn't have enough layers, so you'd get these giant spoonfuls of just pudding without the contrast of wafers. Adding the sweetened condensed milk was actually my college roommate's suggestion - her mom made it that way. Complete game-changer! Recently I've started adding a touch more vanilla than the recipe calls for, which really makes all the flavors pop.

Serving Ideas

For family dinners, I just serve it straight out of the dish I made it in. But when I'm trying to impress people, I'll make it in a trifle bowl so you can see all those pretty layers. For potlucks, I sometimes do individual mason jars, which people go crazy for. My sister-in-law does a "banana pudding bar" where she puts out the pudding with extra bananas, wafers, and toppings like toasted coconut and chocolate chips so people can customize their own.

Tasty Twists

Sometimes I'll throw in some sliced strawberries between layers - the strawberry-banana combo is killer. My chocolate-obsessed husband loves when I use chocolate pudding mix instead of vanilla. For grown-up dinner parties, try stirring a couple tablespoons of bourbon into the pudding mixture - not enough to taste boozy, just enough to add depth. My personal favorite twist is adding a thin layer of dulce de leche over each banana layer. Completely unnecessary but absolutely worth it.

Storage Smarts

This keeps in the fridge for about 3 days before the bananas start to get funky. Cover it tightly with plastic wrap - I press mine right onto the surface of the pudding to prevent that weird skin from forming. Don't even think about freezing leftovers... defrosted bananas are just nasty. If you need to make it ahead for something special, you can mix up the pudding part and store it separately, then slice bananas and assemble a few hours before serving.

Pin it

Pudding Perfection

Save a few perfect wafers to decorate the top right before serving
For the most striking presentation, make sure your serving dish is clear glass
If you're feeling fancy, crush a few wafers to dust over the top for that bakery look

Look, I've made this banana pudding so many times I could probably do it blindfolded. It's been to family reunions, church potlucks, office parties, and late-night comfort sessions on my couch during breakups. There's something about it that just makes people happy. Maybe it's nostalgia, maybe it's just the perfect combination of flavors and textures, but I have yet to find someone who doesn't love it. Even my friend who "doesn't like bananas" somehow always manages to eat a huge serving. That's the magic of banana pudding - it's greater than the sum of its parts.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make banana pudding ahead of time?

Yes, banana pudding is actually better when made ahead! Prepare it up to 24 hours in advance for the best flavor and texture as the vanilla wafers have time to soften.

→ How can I prevent my bananas from turning brown?

Make sure your banana slices are completely covered with the pudding mixture to minimize exposure to air. Adding a small splash of lemon juice to the banana slices can also help, but use sparingly to avoid altering the flavor.

→ Can I use homemade whipped cream instead of whipped topping?

Absolutely! Whip 2 cups of heavy cream with 1/4 cup of powdered sugar until stiff peaks form. Fold this into your pudding mixture instead of the whipped topping for a more homemade flavor.

→ What's the best dish to serve banana pudding in?

A clear glass trifle bowl shows off the beautiful layers, but a 9x13 baking dish or any 2-3 quart serving dish works well. Individual serving cups or mason jars are also a fun presentation option.

→ Can I use banana pudding mix instead of vanilla?

Yes, you can substitute banana pudding mix for the vanilla if you prefer a stronger banana flavor. The dessert will be slightly sweeter with a more pronounced banana taste.

→ How long does banana pudding last in the refrigerator?

Banana pudding is best enjoyed within 2-3 days of preparation. After that, the bananas may begin to break down and the texture will change, though it remains safe to eat.