Pin it
My Marinated Cheese Appetizer has saved countless parties and last minute gatherings. I stumbled upon this combination of creamy havarti cheese salami tangy cornichons and buttery olives years ago when preparing for an impromptu wine night. Now it's my go to recipe when friends pop over. The magic happens when everything soaks in my favorite garlicky vinaigrette turning simple ingredients into something absolutely wonderful.
The Perfect Party Starter
I love how this appetizer looks so fancy but takes barely any effort to put together. Sometimes I serve it as the centerpiece of a cheese board other times I arrange it on a platter with some crusty bread. The best part? I can make it days ahead and it just gets better with time. My friends always beg for the recipe after trying it.
What You'll Need
- Havarti Cheese: My favorite for its creamy texture but I've used everything from mozzarella to aged cheddar with great results.
- Salami: Adds that perfect salty bite though sometimes I skip it for my vegetarian friends.
- Sun-Dried Tomatoes: These little flavor bombs are essential in my version but marinated peppers work beautifully too.
- Cornichon Pickles: These tiny French pickles add such a lovely tang regular pickles work in a pinch.
- Castelvetrano Olives: I'm obsessed with their buttery flavor but any olives you love will do.
- Fresh Basil: From my garden when possible it adds such a lovely fresh note.
- Garlic Expressions Dressing: My secret weapon but I'll share my homemade version too.
- Extra Goodies: Sometimes I toss in red pepper flakes green onions or even tiny mozzarella balls.
Let's Put It Together
- Prep Your Goodies
- First I cut everything into perfect bite sized pieces. The key is making them small enough to pop in your mouth but big enough to spear with a toothpick.
- Mix and Mingle
- All those lovely ingredients go into my big blue mixing bowl. I love watching the colors come together.
- The Magic Sauce
- I pour that gorgeous garlicky dressing over everything and give it all a gentle toss. Every bite should get some of that flavor.
- Time to Rest
- Everything gets tucked into my favorite mason jar and into the fridge. The waiting is the hardest part.
- Party Time
- I always let it come to room temperature before serving. The flavors really bloom that way.
Pin it
My Best Tips
After making this countless times I've learned a few tricks. Taking the cheese out of the fridge early helps it soak up all those lovely flavors. Overnight marinating works wonders though I've left it up to a week and it's incredible. I always set out little cocktail forks saves everyone from sticky fingers. For my keto friends I serve it with cucumber rounds instead of crackers.
Why Everyone Loves This
This appetizer has become my signature party dish. The way the cheese soaks up the marinade while staying creamy and the perfect balance of tangy briny and fresh flavors makes everyone come back for seconds. Plus I can make it ahead and actually enjoy my own party.
Make It Your Own
- No Meat Needed: I often make it veggie style with extra roasted vegetables.
- Cheese Adventures: Sometimes I mix different cheeses for fun textures.
- Spice It Up: A pinch of chili flakes makes everything exciting.
- Herb Garden: Whatever herbs look fresh in my garden go right in.
- Sweet Surprises: Dried cranberries add lovely little pops of sweetness.
Keep It Fresh
This appetizer keeps beautifully in the fridge for up to a week though it rarely lasts that long in my house. Just remember to pull it out about an hour before serving the flavors are so much better at room temperature. I love setting it out with an assortment of crackers crusty bread and fresh vegetables letting everyone choose their perfect bite.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long can I marinate this?
It keeps up to a week in the fridge. Flavors develop more over time but it's ready to serve immediately.
- → What vinaigrette works best?
Any Italian-style garlic vinaigrette works. Choose one you enjoy as it heavily influences the final taste.
- → Can I use different cheese?
Semi-soft cheeses like gouda or young cheddar work well. Avoid very soft or crumbly cheeses.
- → What can I substitute for cornichons?
Any small pickles work. Dill gherkins provide similar tangy crunch.
- → How should I serve this?
Serve with toothpicks as finger food or alongside crackers and bread. Bring to room temperature before serving.
Conclusion
A quick and easy appetizer that transforms simple ingredients into a delightful party snack. The combination of havarti cheese, salami, and pickles creates a flavorful and impressive dish that can be prepared in advance.