Creamy Mexican Street Corn Cup

Mexican street corn cups are basically elote that somebody decided to serve in a cup instead of on the cob, which makes eating it way less messy while keeping all that creamy, tangy, spicy goodness intact. You char corn kernels in butter until they get those toasty brown spots, mix them with mayo, Mexican crema, lime juice, and chili powder, then serve everything in cups topped with crumbled Cotija cheese and cilantro. The whole thing takes twenty minutes from start to finish and tastes like you're eating street food from a vendor in Mexico City, minus the need to navigate corn stuck in your teeth for the next hour. I discovered this version when my kids refused to eat corn on the cob after my son lost a tooth biting into one and declared all corn "dangerous." Serving the exact same flavors in a cup with a spoon suddenly made it acceptable again, and now they request these corn cups constantly without realizing they're eating the vegetable they claimed to hate. My mother-in-law thinks I've become this creative cook who comes up with fun presentations, and I'm not telling her I just wanted to avoid another tooth-related corn incident.

My friend David is one of those guys who won't eat anything that seems "too messy" or requires getting his hands dirty. He refuses corn on the cob at cookouts, peels pizza before eating it, and generally acts like food is trying to attack him. When I served these corn cups at a party, he ate three servings and declared them "finally, corn I can respect." His wife looked at me with this exhausted expression that said she'd been dealing with his food quirks for years, and now I'd validated his ridiculous behavior by accommodating it. Now he asks for these specifically at gatherings, and I've accidentally enabled his food pickiness by proving that everything can be modified to meet his standards.

What Goes Into Them

• Corn kernels: Four cups worth from fresh ears, grilled corn, or thawed frozen works equally well depending on what's easiest and what season it is.
• Butter: Three tablespoons help char the corn while adding richness and that classic corn-on-the-cob flavor everyone expects.
• Mayonnaise: Three tablespoons add creaminess and help the spices stick to the corn instead of just falling off onto the plate.
• Mexican crema or sour cream: Half a cup creates that tangy, creamy base that makes this taste authentic instead of just being corn with mayo on it.
• Cotija cheese: Crumbled generously on top adds salty, funky flavor that's essential to real Mexican street corn instead of using regular cheese that doesn't taste right.
• Garlic: Minced and optional but highly recommended for depth and savory notes that make this more complex than just sweet corn.
• Jalapeño: Finely chopped and optional for people who want actual heat instead of just the mild warmth from chili powder.
• Lime juice: Freshly squeezed provides bright acidity that cuts through all the richness and makes everything taste lighter and more balanced.
• Chili powder: One teaspoon adds gentle heat and that distinctive reddish color you see on real elote from street vendors.
• Salt: To taste adjusting based on how salty your Cotija and butter are since both contribute significant sodium.
• Fresh cilantro: Chopped and scattered on top adds fresh herbal brightness that makes this taste authentic instead of just being creamy corn.

Pin it

Making These Cups

Charring the corn:

Set a large skillet over medium heat and add your three tablespoons of butter, letting it melt completely and spread across the bottom of the pan. Don't let the butter brown or burn—you just want it melted and hot. Add all your corn kernels to the pan in a relatively even layer. If you're using fresh corn, cut the kernels off the cob by standing each ear on end and slicing down the sides with a sharp knife. Frozen corn should be completely thawed and patted dry with paper towels so excess moisture doesn't make everything steam instead of char. Let the corn sit undisturbed for about 2 to 3 minutes so the kernels touching the pan can develop those golden-brown char marks. Stir everything around, then let it sit undisturbed again for another 2 minutes. Keep repeating this process—stirring occasionally then letting it sit—for a total of 5 to 7 minutes until you see nice brown spots on many of the kernels. You want them lightly charred with toasty caramelized bits but not completely blackened or burnt. Turn off the heat and let the corn cool slightly while you make the creamy mixture.

Making creamy sauce:

Get out a large mixing bowl and add your three tablespoons of mayonnaise along with your half cup of Mexican crema or sour cream. If you're using the optional garlic, add your minced clove now. If you want heat, add your finely chopped jalapeño. Squeeze in the juice from one or two limes depending on how big they are, aiming for about 2 tablespoons of juice total. Sprinkle in your teaspoon of chili powder and a generous pinch of salt. Use a whisk or spoon to stir everything together vigorously until you have a smooth, uniform mixture with the mayo and crema completely blended and the spices distributed throughout. The sauce should be thick and creamy but still pourable, kind of like ranch dressing consistency. Taste it and adjust with more lime juice, salt, or chili powder if needed, remembering that you're about to add salty Cotija on top so don't oversalt at this stage.

Combining everything:

Add your warm, slightly charred corn kernels to the bowl with the creamy sauce. Use a large spoon or spatula to toss everything together, stirring and folding until every kernel gets coated with that creamy, tangy mixture. You want uniform coverage with the white sauce visible on all the corn instead of having dry spots or pools of sauce at the bottom. The warmth from the corn will help the sauce coat better and thin slightly, making it easier to distribute evenly.

Serving in cups:

Get out four individual serving cups—small bowls, plastic cups, mason jars, whatever you have that works for individual portions. Scoop the creamy corn mixture into each cup, dividing it relatively evenly so everyone gets the same amount. Don't pack it down or press it firmly, just scoop it in loosely so the cups look full and abundant. Generously crumble Cotija cheese over the top of each cup, using as much as you want because you can never have too much cheese. Sprinkle a little extra chili powder over each cup for color and additional flavor. Scatter chopped fresh cilantro on top of everything. Cut a lime into wedges and place one or two on the side of each cup for people to squeeze on extra juice if they want.

Things You Should Know

Charring the corn in butter instead of boiling it creates way more flavor through caramelization, turning plain corn into something with actual depth and complexity. Mexican crema is ideal but regular sour cream works fine if that's all you can find, just thin it with a tablespoon of milk if it seems too thick. Cotija cheese is not really substitutable with other cheeses—parmesan or feta are okay in a pinch but they don't taste quite right for authentic street corn flavor.

The first time I made this, I boiled the corn thinking it would be faster than sautéing it. The corn tasted fine but completely lacked that caramelized sweetness and smoky depth you get from charring. It was just...corn with sauce on it, boring and one-dimensional. Taking the time to char the kernels properly makes such a dramatic difference in flavor that it's completely worth the extra ten minutes in a hot pan.

I used regular sour cream for the sauce once when I couldn't find Mexican crema, and while it worked okay, the texture was thicker and the flavor was more tangy and less smooth. Mexican crema has this silky consistency and mild tang that's perfect for this dish, making it taste more authentic. Now I seek it out specifically or make my own by thinning sour cream with a bit of milk and lime juice to approximate that consistency.

The Cotija cheese is what really makes this taste like actual Mexican street corn instead of just being creamy corn salad. I tried using feta once thinking it was close enough since both are crumbly and salty, but feta has this sharper, more aggressive flavor that didn't taste right. Cotija is milder and slightly nutty with a drier texture that's distinctively different. It's worth finding at a Mexican grocery store or well-stocked regular supermarket rather than substituting with something else.

Fresh lime juice matters way more than bottled. I used bottled lime juice once out of laziness and it tasted flat and slightly chemical instead of bright and zesty. Fresh limes take literally thirty seconds to squeeze and transform the whole dish with their vibrant acidity. Don't skip this or use the plastic lime-shaped squeeze bottle—real limes are essential.

The optional jalapeño and garlic really do elevate this from good to great. I made it without them once to keep it simple, and while it was fine, adding minced garlic and some chopped jalapeño makes the flavor so much more complex and interesting without making it spicy enough to scare off kids or sensitive eaters.

Serving These Cups

Serve these corn cups while they're still slightly warm from the pan, when the butter and cheese are at their most aromatic and delicious. They work perfectly as a side dish at barbecues and cookouts, replacing boring steamed corn with something way more interesting. Set them out at parties as a passed appetizer or snack that people can eat with just a spoon while standing around talking. These are ideal for Cinco de Mayo celebrations, taco nights, or any time you're serving Mexican food and want authentic street food vibes. Each cup is substantial enough to work as a side dish but light enough that people can eat them as a snack without feeling overstuffed.

For outdoor gatherings, these cups are genius because there's no corn cob to deal with, no butter dripping everywhere, and no dental floss needed afterward. People can eat them one-handed while holding a drink, which makes socializing way easier than trying to navigate corn on the cob at a standing party. The individual portions also help with portion control and make serving a crowd way simpler than trying to divide up a big bowl of corn salad.

Kids generally love these because they're fun to eat from a cup with a spoon, and the creamy coating makes the corn taste rich and interesting instead of plain. The chili powder adds just enough warmth that it tastes flavorful without being spicy enough to cause complaints. Adults appreciate the authentic flavors and the fact that this tastes like something from a food truck without requiring you to leave your house or wait in line.

The bright colors make these look festive and appealing—golden yellow corn, white creamy sauce, red chili powder, green cilantro, and white Cotija creating this vibrant presentation that photographs well if you're into that. Even people who claim they don't like corn usually enjoy this version because the charring and creamy sauce transform it into something completely different from plain boiled corn.

Different Ways to Try It

• Add grilled poblano peppers diced into the corn for smoky, mild heat and more vegetables throughout.
• Try tajín seasoning instead of plain chili powder for more complex citrus-lime-chili flavor.
• Mix in some black beans for extra protein and to make this more substantial as a main course.
• Add crumbled cooked bacon for smoky, salty richness that makes this even more indulgent.
• Use chipotle powder instead of regular chili for smokier, deeper heat.
• Stir in some cream cheese along with the crema for even richer, thicker sauce.
• Top with crushed hot Cheetos for that Flamin' Hot Cheetos elote version that's popular with kids.
• Add diced avocado on top for creaminess and healthy fats.

Keeping It Fresh

These corn cups are best eaten fresh when they're still warm or at room temperature, but leftovers keep in the refrigerator for up to 3 days stored in an airtight container. The corn will absorb more sauce as it sits, making the texture slightly less creamy, but it still tastes good. Reheat gently in the microwave for about 30 seconds just to take the chill off, or eat it cold as a corn salad-style dish. Don't freeze these because the creamy sauce separates and gets watery when thawed, and the corn texture suffers significantly. The charred corn can be made ahead and stored in the fridge for up to 2 days, then just make the creamy sauce fresh and combine everything when you're ready to serve.

Pin it

I've made these Mexican street corn cups dozens of times since discovering how much easier they are than corn on the cob while tasting just as good if not better. There's something really satisfying about serving street food at home that actually tastes authentic without requiring specialized equipment or hard-to-find ingredients. The combination of sweet charred corn, tangy lime crema, salty Cotija, and mild chili powder hits every flavor note perfectly, creating this addictive mix that keeps you going back for more. My family requests these constantly during summer when corn is cheap and abundant, but I've also made them year-round with frozen corn when we're craving those flavors in January. I love that they're accidentally vegetarian and gluten-free without trying to be, making them work for basically everyone at mixed gatherings where dietary restrictions are always a concern. These have become my default corn preparation, completely replacing plain corn on the cob or boring steamed corn in my household. The individual cup presentation makes everything feel more special and intentional instead of just being a vegetable side dish, elevating simple corn into something people actually get excited about eating!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use canned corn instead?

You can, but drain it really well and pat it dry before cooking. Fresh or frozen corn will have better flavor and texture though.

→ What can I use instead of Cotija cheese?

Feta cheese is the closest substitute. Parmesan also works in a pinch. Both have that salty, crumbly texture you want.

→ Is Mexican crema the same as sour cream?

They're similar but Mexican crema is a bit thinner and less tangy. Sour cream works fine as a substitute, or you can thin it with a little milk.

→ How spicy is this with the jalapeño?

It adds a mild kick but isn't overwhelming. Leave out the jalapeño if you want it mild, or keep the seeds in for more heat.

→ Can I make this ahead of time?

The corn mixture holds up well in the fridge for a day. Just wait to add the toppings until right before serving so everything stays fresh and crunchy.

→ Do I have to serve this in cups?

Not at all! You can serve it family-style in a big bowl or even as a side dish on plates. The cups just make it fun for parties and easy to eat.