Pin it
One-pan balsamic chicken has saved my sanity on countless busy weeknights. Picture this: juicy chicken swimming in a sticky-sweet balsamic glaze, topped with melty mozzarella and bursting tomatoes. I stumbled upon this combination years ago when trying to use up some fresh mozzarella, and it's been my back-pocket recipe ever since.
Last week I made this for my sister's family, and my picky 6-year-old niece actually asked for seconds. Trust me, that's the highest praise any recipe can get in our family.
Essential Ingredients Guide
- Fresh mozzarella pearls: Don't even think about using the pre-shredded stuff. Those little balls of fresh mozz turn into pockets of creamy heaven
- Balsamic vinegar: Splurge a little here. A good balsamic will be slightly thick and complex, not just sour
- Grape tomatoes: Cherry tomatoes work too, but grape tomatoes hold their shape better while baking
- Chicken breasts: Look for pieces that are roughly the same size. Mine always seem to come in wildly different sizes until I give them a good pounding
Pin it
Detailed Cooking Instructions
- Get Your Sauce Together:
- Pour that balsamic vinegar into a bowl - it should ribbon off your spoon a bit
- Drizzle in your honey while whisking. The honey helps create that glossy finish we're after
- Add your oil in a steady stream - this keeps everything from separating later
- Toss in those minced garlic cloves. I always add an extra one because, well, it's garlic
- Sprinkle in Italian seasoning and whisk in Dijon mustard until it looks silky smooth
- Prep Your Chicken:
- Here's where those chicken-pounding biceps come in handy
- Put each breast between plastic wrap (learned this the hard way after cleaning chicken bits off my ceiling)
- Give them a good pounding until they're even. Think about your annoying neighbor if it helps
- Pat them dry really well - wet chicken = no browning, and browning = flavor
- Tomato-Mozz Magic:
- Slice those tomatoes in half - don't worry about being too precise
- If you've got the cherry-sized mozzarella balls, cut them in half. The tiny ones can stay whole
- Tear up that fresh basil. Sure, you could chop it, but torn basil just hits different
- Toss it all together in a bowl. Give it a pinch of salt - the tomatoes really wake up with a bit of seasoning
- Let's Get Cooking:
- Get your pan nice and hot - you should see tiny wisps of smoke from the oil
- Lay those chicken breasts in carefully. That sizzle sound? That's the sound of deliciousness
- Leave them alone! I mean it. No poking, no checking for 2 whole minutes
- Pour that balsamic mixture around the edges of the pan, not on top of your beautifully browned chicken
- Top with your tomato-cheese mixture and pop it in the oven
The first time I made this, my kitchen smelled so good that my neighbor actually texted to ask what I was cooking. Now it's become our unofficial Sunday dinner swap recipe - she makes it for her family one week, I make it for mine the next.
Making It Work For You
Sometimes I switch things up based on what's in my fridge. Last month I discovered that throwing in some baby spinach under the tomatoes works beautifully - it gets all wilted and soaks up that balsamic sauce like a dream. My husband actually high-fived me for that one.
The Sauce Secret
You know that gorgeous sauce at the bottom of the pan? Don't you dare let it go to waste. I've started keeping a crusty loaf of bread on hand specifically for soaking up every last drop. My mother-in-law thinks I'm fancy, but really, I'm just practical about not wasting liquid gold.
Pin it
Chef's Helpful Tips
- Take your chicken out of the fridge 15 minutes before cooking - cold meat equals tough meat
- Got leftovers? Slice them thin and throw them on a salad tomorrow. You're welcome
- When in doubt, add more garlic. I've never once regretted this decision
Listen, I've probably made this dish a hundred times now, and it still makes me happy every single time I watch those cheese pulls as I serve it. There's something magical about how a few simple ingredients can transform into something that makes people think you spent hours in the kitchen. Between us, it's my go-to "I want them to think I have my life together" dinner party dish.
Want my final piece of advice? Double the sauce recipe. Trust me on this one - you'll want extra for drizzling, dipping, or just eating with a spoon (no judgment here, we've all been there). And if anyone asks, just tell them it's an old family recipe. Sometimes the best traditions are the ones we create ourselves.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why pound the chicken?
- Ensures even cooking and tender meat. Don't skip this step for best results.
- → What size mozzarella should I use?
- Ciliegine (cherry size) cut in half, or smaller pearl size left whole.
- → Can I make this ahead?
- Best served fresh, but you can prep components separately ahead of time.
- → What pan should I use?
- Any large oven-safe skillet or pan that can go from stovetop to oven.
- → What can I serve with this?
- Pasta, rice, or crusty bread to soak up the sauce.